Eredan iTCG BrasileiroEredan iTCG DeutschEredan iTCG EspañolEredan iTCG ItalianoEredan iTCG FrançaisEredan iTCG English
Nous sommes actuellement le 27 Juin 2025, 14:36
Publier une réponse Page 1 sur 2   [ 11 message(s) ]
Aller vers la page 1, 2  Suivant
Auteur Message
 Sujet du message : cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 26 Juillet 2013, 23:16 
Aventurier

Inscription : 22 Mars 2013, 02:47
Message(s) : 54
Image

here is an image of "the undead's night" that's valid in standard format. but then, how the hell do the cards it creates, "they are everywhere" and "braiiiiin?", get inside the format when they aren't valid for play there in the first place? isn't this going against the division implemented by the said standard filter?

although i can't put the actual cards in my deck and play them since they are not allowed in the standard format, there's another card that can bypass that restriction by creating a "token"(not my word, but it came from someone whom i had a talk with regarding this query) card copy of those said cards.

does that make any sense to you? kindly give me your thoughts guys.

the big thing that bothers me is that there are cards that do the same thing that are in standard also, but do not cross this said "boundary".

here is a screenshot of coat armor with boldness in the background. they are both playable in standard. coat armor when played by a the pack character creates and plays a boldness, nothing wrong there. do you see my point?

Image


Dernière édition par David_Marcial le 28 Juillet 2013, 09:58, édité 1 fois.

Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
 Sujet du message : Re: cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 27 Juillet 2013, 00:25 
Duelliste

Inscription : 09 Avril 2013, 10:43
Message(s) : 45
David_Marcial a écrit :
Image

here is an image of "the undead's night" that's valid in standard format. but then, how the hell do the cards it creates, "they are everywhere" and "braiiiiin?", get inside the format when they aren't valid for play there in the first place? isn't this going against the division implemented by the said standard filter?

although i can't put the actual cards in my deck and play them since they are not allowed in the standard format, there's another card that can bypass that restriction by creating a "token"(not my word, but it came from someone whom i had a talk with regarding this query) card copy of those said cards.

does that make any sense to you? kindly give me your thoughts guys.


I don't see a point in discussing this. Just imagine them as 2 seperate effects which you pick. Don't see them as playing cards as they don't go into your discard pile or anything.


Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
 Sujet du message : Re: cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 27 Juillet 2013, 00:50 
Guémélite
Avatar de l’utilisateur

Inscription : 21 Février 2013, 14:18
Message(s) : 227
mangg a écrit :
David_Marcial a écrit :
Image

here is an image of "the undead's night" that's valid in standard format. but then, how the hell do the cards it creates, "they are everywhere" and "braiiiiin?", get inside the format when they aren't valid for play there in the first place? isn't this going against the division implemented by the said standard filter?

although i can't put the actual cards in my deck and play them since they are not allowed in the standard format, there's another card that can bypass that restriction by creating a "token"(not my word, but it came from someone whom i had a talk with regarding this query) card copy of those said cards.

does that make any sense to you? kindly give me your thoughts guys.


I don't see a point in discussing this. Just imagine them as 2 seperate effects which you pick. Don't see them as playing cards as they don't go into your discard pile or anything.


I think the cards created DO go in your discard pile.

_________________
Eredan Kickstarter


Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
 Sujet du message : Re: cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 29 Juillet 2013, 06:00 
Marchand

Inscription : 05 Février 2013, 01:21
Message(s) : 536
well, for the undead night's created cards they disappear after the length of the cards duration is over ie. 1 fight or 2 fights

_________________
Ty Boadicea for the awesome farewell gift. Now just to think up an avatar to go with it. Anyway, I'm still a Sap/Nomad/Pirates fan and user.


Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
 Sujet du message : Re: cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 29 Juillet 2013, 11:40 
Duelliste

Inscription : 09 Avril 2013, 10:43
Message(s) : 45
They do not go in the graveyard.


Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
 Sujet du message : Re: cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 20 Août 2013, 01:45 
Aventurier

Inscription : 12 Février 2013, 18:49
Message(s) : 96
the point is valid. Also the point that cards that have almost similar effects but played by different guilds are not all allowed in standard. For example: crows are allowed to play that benediction card that heals 5-8 per battle, but saps are not allowed to play feign death that heals 5 per battle. Also the crow card is permanent and the sap card is 2 fights long. So what can be played or not in standard is usually somehow random. One thing is for sure.... most epic cards are banned.
The rest depend on which guild they want to favor or not.


Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
 Sujet du message : Re: cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 21 Août 2013, 06:44 
Duelliste

Inscription : 09 Avril 2013, 10:43
Message(s) : 45
DalarasCroft a écrit :
the point is valid. Also the point that cards that have almost similar effects but played by different guilds are not all allowed in standard. For example: crows are allowed to play that benediction card that heals 5-8 per battle, but saps are not allowed to play feign death that heals 5 per battle. Also the crow card is permanent and the sap card is 2 fights long. So what can be played or not in standard is usually somehow random. One thing is for sure.... most epic cards are banned.
The rest depend on which guild they want to favor or not.


You don't seem to understand the logic of playing formats mate. The card restrictions are not based on what they do but what sets they belong. The logic is not; oh let's have all the guilds have cards that do similar stuff. All that matters is if they belong to the last 3 sets or not. The not allowed cards are those that are found too OP for the so called format and are banned due to the unfairness they bring across the board. Cards such as thunderstruck and the mask are fine examples to this. I do agree though. With this logic they should ban at least 2 crow cards or at least nerf them a little.


Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
 Sujet du message : Re: cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 21 Août 2013, 07:50 
Aventurier

Inscription : 22 Mars 2013, 02:47
Message(s) : 54
mangg a écrit :

You don't seem to understand the logic of playing formats mate. The card restrictions are not based on what they do but what sets they belong. The logic is not; oh let's have all the guilds have cards that do similar stuff. All that matters is if they belong to the last 3 sets or not. The not allowed cards are those that are found too OP for the so called format and are banned due to the unfairness they bring across the board. Cards such as thunderstruck and the mask are fine examples to this. I do agree though. With this logic they should ban at least 2 crow cards or at least nerf them a little.


So mangg, I'm just curious to know. Do I present a valid point here?


Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
 Sujet du message : Re: cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 21 Août 2013, 13:14 
Duelliste

Inscription : 09 Avril 2013, 10:43
Message(s) : 45
David_Marcial a écrit :
mangg a écrit :

You don't seem to understand the logic of playing formats mate. The card restrictions are not based on what they do but what sets they belong. The logic is not; oh let's have all the guilds have cards that do similar stuff. All that matters is if they belong to the last 3 sets or not. The not allowed cards are those that are found too OP for the so called format and are banned due to the unfairness they bring across the board. Cards such as thunderstruck and the mask are fine examples to this. I do agree though. With this logic they should ban at least 2 crow cards or at least nerf them a little.


So mangg, I'm just curious to know. Do I present a valid point here?


No dude, you most certainly do not. You need to consider those as effects. If they have removed the card names and arts, put 2 new cards instead with different names and art which have done the same thing, you wouldn't even think about making this post. Those cards cannot be played separately, they are 2 separate effects you get to chose from playing a card. It really isn't that hard to grasp. You cannot replay them from your graveyard, they are just created cards. The card that creates the 2 cards are valid in standard, that is all that matters.

I really don't see discussing this subject any further, as it doesn't make any sense. It is probably the most pointless thing we can discuss about eredan right now.

Now if you were ranting about I could understand your logic. It is an uncommon card that creates a rare card, which is also standard valid. This would make a little bit more sense.

But really, what we have been discussing here is rather pointless.


Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
 Sujet du message : Re: cards crossing boundaries
Message Publié : 21 Août 2013, 13:42 
Aventurier

Inscription : 22 Mars 2013, 02:47
Message(s) : 54
mangg a écrit :
No dude, you most certainly do not. You need to consider those as effects. If they have removed the card names and arts, put 2 new cards instead with different names and art which have done the same thing, you wouldn't even think about making this post. Those cards cannot be played separately, they are 2 separate effects you get to chose from playing a card. It really isn't that hard to grasp. You cannot replay them from your graveyard, they are just created cards. The card that creates the 2 cards are valid in standard, that is all that matters.

I really don't see discussing this subject any further, as it doesn't make any sense. It is probably the most pointless thing we can discuss about eredan right now.

Now if you were ranting about I could understand your logic. It is an uncommon card that creates a rare card, which is also standard valid. This would make a little bit more sense.

But really, what we have been discussing here is rather pointless.


As for , is in standard, isn't. And it's not about rarity. No need to talk about that one. I would just like to point out that cards have to have a sense of continuity. If it isn't listed on that set of cards, it shouldn't appear in any way in that set.


Haut
 Hors-ligne Profil  
 
Afficher les messages publiés depuis :  Trier par  
Publier une réponse Page 1 sur 2   [ 11 message(s) ]
Aller vers la page 1, 2  Suivant


Qui est en ligne ?

Utilisateur(s) parcourant ce forum : Aucun utilisateur inscrit et 0 invité(s)


Vous ne pouvez pas publier de nouveaux sujets dans ce forum
Vous ne pouvez pas répondre aux sujets dans ce forum
Vous ne pouvez pas éditer vos messages dans ce forum
Vous ne pouvez pas supprimer vos messages dans ce forum
Vous ne pouvez pas insérer de pièces jointes dans ce forum

Recherche de :
Aller vers :  

Propulsé par phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
Traduction et support en françaisHébergement phpBB